Talk:Mackenzie Calhoun

I realize we're already pushing the line by listing the novels, comics, etc. But I wonder if it's a good idea — at this stage, anyway — to have full articles on non-canon subjects, even if the information is clearly marked as non-canon. This needs discussion and resolution.

It's not that I have a problem with the article, really, it's just that allowing articles of this type might end up opening the floodgates to non-canon material. Because what happens next, when we start getting articles that are about canon subjects but also include non-canon material? This could end up getting very confusing, IMO. But I don't want to delete this article yet, because it seems very well-written. :-) -- Dan Carlson 16:36, 16 May 2004 (CEST)


 * I was planning to list it at VfD. While a good article, it is non-canon, and not meta-Trek, so the rule for that does not apply. It should perhaps be included in a general article on the Star Trek: New Frontier books (which would be meta-Trek, and thus non-canon is permitted)? -- Michael Warren 18:14, 16 May 2004 (CEST)