Talk:Earth (mirror)

Un-redirect
You know, I might have to renege on my previous thoughts about this being a redirect versus its own article. While a species is still a species, no matter what universe it is in (its history being the variable); I think in the case of this, there is a difference. Mirror Earth is no more Earth than Mirror Sisko is Sisko. They are composed of the same matter-genes-design, yes, but they are also two separate individual parts of their respective universe. We saw Mirror Earth in ENT, just like we saw Mirror Kirk in TOS. What's the difference? --Alan del Beccio 05:53, 21 February 2008 (UTC)


 * I think the (at least implicit, don't know if we've written down that somewhere) convention has been to create seperate articles if we know enough about the topic, and redirect if we don't. We know enough about Mirror Sisko to warrant an own article, and we don't know enough about "Random mirror universe species", so we have just one article.
 * The information currently in the "Mirror universe" section of Earth seems to put it on the fence, really. It could become its own article, although that one would stay a short one... -- Cid Highwind 12:49, 22 February 2008 (UTC)