Memory Alpha talk:Episode data project/status

I've checked TOS with the most convenient resource I had: a listing in a special edition magazine from 1996 called "Star Trek: 30 Years."

Here are some minor problems:
 * 1)  has a stardate range not in the magazine, but I verified it with Chakoteya's transcript.
 * 2)  has Ralph Senensky credited as director, based on information in his article. This needs to be confirmed. Anyone know a source for this?
 * 3)  has Unknown as stardate, but the magazine lists it as "2534.0", matching StarTrek.com's information.
 * 4) 's stardate is 5121.5, but the magazine says "5121.0"; StarTrek.com agrees with us.
 * 5)  has Unknown as stardate, but the magazine lists it as "4598.0", and the "Teleplay By" credit lists Gene L. Coon, but he is not credited in the magazine. StarTrek.com agrees with the magazine on the stardate, but agrees with us on the credit.

Any information/comments? --Bp 08:27, 13 January 2007 (UTC)


 * Some of the stardates you have referenced above in that magazine also appear in the 1976 Star Trek Concordance-- the oldest confirmation of the dates reference (I have). Either way, I have the confirmed information you requested listed below:


 * : Stardate range: 3417.3 - 3417.7
 * : Herb Wallerstein was the only one credited on screen; Ralph Senensky's "uncredited" reference needs to be somehow cited or removed.
 * : No stardate (episode)/2534.0 (Concordance)
 * : Stardate 5121.5 (episode)/5121.0 (Concordance)
 * : No stardate (episode)/4598.0 (Concordance); Teleplay in the article page is correctly listed to credits. Sum it all: The MA article data is correct.
 * I have that magazine too, and have noticed other errors in it as well, and personally wouldn't use as a canon guide. --Alan del Beccio 23:03, 13 January 2007 (UTC)


 * Excellent, thank you. --Bp 00:52, 14 January 2007 (UTC)